Nature vs. Nurture vs. Torture

So, you thought your parents were too strict?

Were you grounded when you had brought home an “F”?  Did you have to go to bed without dessert if you didn’t clean your hamster cage?  Were you not allowed to watch a late-night showing of a Freddy Krueger flick on a school night?

What goes around...

What goes around...

Don’t know about you, but I certainly felt supremely used when either of the above chanced to happen.

But after reading a recent report published on life.ru about parents so concerned with their 12-year old’s GPA, they kept him from using a bathroom and stuck hot peppers in his mouth and anus if he brought home a Russian equivalent of an “F”, well, lemme tell you, my inner child is feeling chastised.

Abuse by those you trust the most is to me so much worse than the comparable wrong done to you by a stranger.

You are not expecting those nearest and dearest to do you wrong, and when they do…I think the hurt goes deep.  So deep, many never completely recover.  And those that do not, yet make it through childhood alive — if scarred, in more ways than one — all too often grow up doomed to repeat the same cycle of behavior.  In fact, even infants subsequently adopted out into loving household are now considered at risk for abusive behavioral patterns.  No, it is not a classic argument in favor of nature winning over nurture.

Quite the opposite, in fact.  The theory is, infant abuse in early stages of life may lead to the lowered production of seratonin, a chemical responsible for transmitting brain impulses, the depressed levels of which have long been known to cause anxiety, depression, and impulsive aggression.  The study extending this disturbing school of thought to our youngest members is based on the effects of maternal neglect and abuse on baby rhesus monkeys, whose metabolism and reaction to stress has often proved very similar to that of humans.

Even now not altogether understood, the infant failure to thrive has been a medical staple for many decades.  The failure to develop into an emotionally healthy adult based solely on upbringing in the first few months of life is something that is, also, beginning to make rounds in the professional cycles.

Not to say we are doomed to repeat the mistakes of our not so stellar family members.  There are people referred to among behavioral researchers as “resilient” and they are carefully studied – with their consent – for the purpose for of developing programs for “at risk” populace and implementing them as means of preventing the spread of this trend to new generations.

Meanwhile, though, are children are left to rely on civic authorities to protect them from those who have given them life and yet are prepared to make it a living hell for any and all perceived infraction.  But all too often, the authorities fail — either because of frank societal indifference or a gross negligence on the part of the people in charge.

In the case with the disciplinarian couple referenced higher, well, it has to be the former, because action has been taken, just in a mindbogglingly insufficient way.  Having been reported to the police by the boy’s teachers, this particular set of role models was found to have severely whipped their son for every conceivable misdemeanor in addition to their creative means of assuring his study ethics — and convicted by Voronezh court system of cruelty to a minor, sentenced to…8, I repeat, 8 months in a state penitentiary.  With, because it is not separately stated, I assume a possibility of an early parole.

I really and truly do not understand the logic.  Nor, for that matter, do I understand the utter lack of any sort of outrage on the part of the local journalists bringing us that blurb.

Do we have to be cruel to be kind?

Do we have to be cruel to be kind?

There was such a matter-of-factedness in that description, that not even the parents’ contemptible behavior has shocked me the deepest in this sorry mess.  What does it say about the society where this is practically the norm?  And what does it say about our own country, where prohibitive sentencing is practiced and yet, we have equally if not the more disturbing cases coming to light every day?

Is such violence actually bred into us by this point that no amount of prosecution can, at least, scare it out of those prone to it through our genetic and / or learned blueprint?

These icons link to social bookmarking sites where readers can share and discover new web pages.
  • Digg
  • Reddit
  • TwitThis
  • Technorati
  • del.icio.us
  • StumbleUpon
  • Google Bookmarks
  • Allvoices
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • MySpace
  • Mixx
  • Propeller
  • YahooMyWeb
Blog Traffic Exchange Related Posts
  • Those historians are dogged.  Dogged, I tell you!Let the Sleeping Dogs... What do you do when all the problems of the world are solved? There is no Chrysler bankruptcy setting a pall over the sputtering global markets.  No swine flu among other things, bringing restaurant business in Mexico City to a grinding halt.  No neo-Nazis burning synagogues and painting crude messages......
  • Rageholics Beware.  Cometh stiff competition!When you say, fiery rage... When I was a teen, I used to -- LITERALLY -- beat the stuffing out of my debonair pink flamingo in a black top hat whenever I was feeling pissy.  Those hormones raging like Cali wildfires stoked by Santa Ana winds, let me tell you, that flamingo suffered. [/caption] But......
  • jesus of the electricTo Lay or Not to Lay (Blame) "Hypothermia shuts the whole system down, slowly," [/caption] Said Kanu Virani, a medical examiner for the Oakland County, Michigan. Having completed extensive state-mandated training, he knows what he is talking about. Did other municipal Bay City authorities enjoy even a fraction thereof? Sure, we could hold the utility company responsible......
  • Cattus InterruptusBack to the Future My cat is 2.5 years old.  In cat years...let's round it to 20. Masha is a purebred.  Top of the line Traditional Siamese.  Seven generations of her ancestors have documented pedigrees.  Her mom's a breed standard, check the Wiki.  And no, this isn't a cat personals post -- though considering......
  • Sorry whitey, youre the odd one out!Affirmative Inaction (or, Sudden Onset of Foot-in-Mouth Disease) Soapbox! Loudspeaker, stat! Full glass of raw eggs (supposedly does marvels for the vocal cords)! All right, we’re set. In November, the student association in Ottawa, Ontario, voted to eliminate a Cystic Fibrosis organization from the list of the charities it supports, explaining that since the condition almost exclusively......
Blog Traffic Exchange Related Websites
  • no bullshitMost People that Tell You They Don’t Want to be Wealthy are Lying This post is completely inspired by a post by a recent tongue in cheek post (I swear I have never used that saying before, and I don't think I will again) by Joe over at Personal Finance by The Book titled “How to Ensure That You Will Never Be A......
  • blog traffic exchangeStrategy For Living The topic of strategy might seem confusing. You might ask yourself, "What does strategy have to do with spirituality?" This would reflect the common thinking on the general class of topics we lump together as spirituality. We all have intentions, good or bad, wise or unwise. Your daily life is......
  • blog traffic exchangeFind Your Confidence: Confidence boosters for the new college grad Graduating from college gives you a great feeling and a sense of accomplishment. However, it is usually accompanied by a lurking fear about having to grapple with the nitty-gritty of life that henceforth was not a direct concern. The need for searching suitable job openings for employment to settle down......
  • blog traffic exchangeI have good news, and bad news ... John Anderson, a brilliant mathematician and one of my favorite professors at college, had quite a way with words as well. On one of my papers I made a silly algebra error (I think it was equating the sum of the squares with the square of the sum) and he......
  • Flying Spaghetti MonsterDarkness Teaches Darkness is a part of spirituality, yet there is a trend to censor it in some spiritual groups. No one really likes to talk about the bad side of things, and part of the reason they don’t is either an idea that it somehow makes their efforts impure, or just......

Leave a Comment

Please note: Comment moderation is enabled and may delay your comment. There is no need to resubmit your comment.